INTRODUCTION
FORMATION
OF A MUTUAL FUND
The
Sponsor
The
Trustees
The
AMC
Other
Supporting Entities
PROS
OF MUTUAL FUND INVESTING
Professional
Management and Informed Decision Making
Investment
Flexibility
Portfolio
diversity
Transparency
and Safety
Tax
Benefits
CONS
OF MUTUAL FUND INVESTING
Impact
Cost
Lead
Time
Marketing
and Fund management costs
Cost
of churn
TAX
BENEFITS AND IMPLICATIONS OF INVESTING IN MUTUAL FUNDS
EXPENSES
TYPES
OF MUTUAL FUNDS
Mutual
funds based on structure
Open
ended and close-ended schemes
Load
and No Load Funds
Cumulative
or growth schemes, dividend reinvestment schemes and dividend payout schemes
Mutual
funds based on the Portfolio Allocation
Equity
Funds
* Diversified
funds
* Sector
funds
* Theme
based funds
* Index
funds
* Exchange
Traded Funds
* Equity
Linked Savings Schemes
* Mid-cap,
Large-cap, Small-cap, Multi-cap Funds
* Dividend
Yield Funds
* Contra
Funds
Debt
Funds
* Short
term debt funds
* Medium
term debt funds
* Long
term debt funds
* Pension
schemes
* Floating
Rate Funds
* Gilt
Funds
* Fixed
maturity Plans (FMPs)
Balanced
Funds
* Monthly
Income Plans (MIPs)
* Dynamic
Asset Allocation Funds
Other
Types of Funds
* Fund
of Funds
* Evaluation
and Monitoring of a Mutual Fund Scheme
* Arbitrage
funds
* Hedge
Funds
* Gold
Exchange Traded Funds (GETFs)
* Realty
Funds
EVALUATION
AND MONITORING OF A MUTUAL FUND SCHEME
Net
Asset Value (NAV) – A basic tool
Quantitative
measures using the NAV on a stand alone basis
Appreciation/Depreciation
of the NAV
Total
Return Method
Return
with Dividend Reinvestment Option
Measuring
Performance vis-à-vis Benchmark
AMFI
Indices
MUTUAL
FUND INVESTING STRATEGIES
Systematic
Investment Plans
Systematic
Withdrawal Plans
Systematic
Transfer Plans
MUTUAL
FUNDS v/s PORTFOLIO MANAGEMENT SERVICES
CHECKLIST
FOR MUTUAL FUND INVESTING
MYTH
BUSTERS
JARGON
BUSTER
INTRODUCTION
To benefit from investing in the stock or the debt market, you
must have a basic understanding of how these function and a good overview of
what is on offer. Beyond that, it requires continuous tracking of various
stocks and/or debt market products, in order to stay abreast with the trends in
these markets. For example, if you buy shares of ten companies, it means that
you will have to keep a close tab on these ten companies in terms of their
performance, financial results, future plans and so on. In the case of debt, to
invest gainfully, you must be aware of trends in inflation and interest rates,
amongst other factors, not only in the domestic market but in international
markets as well.
This may sound like a daunting task as it could take up a lot
of your time and effort. It would also require access to a considerable amount
of information, in addition to having suitable skills and expertise. The simple
alternative would be to invest in debt and equity through mutual funds.
A mutual fund is a vehicle through which an investor can
indirectly invest in equities or the debt instruments. It holds the
contributions of a large number of investors and the common pool of funds so
collected is invested by professional managers in equities and/or debt
instruments in accordance with the predefined objectives of the mutual fund.
Since the ownership of the corpus is joint, i.e., the fund belongs to all
investors, and its investment purpose is “mutual”, i.e., common for all
investors, it is called a mutual fund.
In proportion to their contributions, investors receive units
of the mutual fund. At the outset, the units issued have a face value of Rs 10
each. Later, as the corpus is invested and the value of the investments change
the value of each unit changes proportionately. The value of each unit is also
impacted when management fees and other expenses are deducted from the overall
pool of funds.
The value of each unit is called the Net Asset Value or NAV of
the scheme. It changes on a daily basis. As per the definition, the net assets
mean the current market price of all securities held plus cash and any accrued
income, minus liabilities.
More specifically,
NAV = (Market value of the fund's investments + Current assets + Accrued
income) - Current Liabilities - Accrued Expenses / (Total Number of units
outstanding)
Investors who wish to purchase or sell units of a mutual fund after the scheme
is fully functional must do so at a price that is linked to the NAV.
Top
FORMATION
OF A MUTUAL FUND
The domestic mutual fund industry is governed by the Securities and Exchange
Board of India, Mutual Fund regulations and the Indian Trusts Act, 1882.
A mutual fund is constituted as a public trust created under
the Indian Trusts Act, 1882 and has a three tier structure, in order to prevent
potential conflicts of interest. The three main entities are the Sponsor, the
Board of Trustees and the Asset Management Company (AMC).
The Sponsor
The sponsor of a mutual fund is the promoter who establishes a mutual fund and
gets it registered with SEBI. The sponsor also forms a ‘trust’ and appoints a
Board of Trustees to ensure that the mutual fund adheres to all the rules and
regulation framed by the regulator.
The Trustees
The Board of Trustees is responsible for protecting investors’ interests and
ensuring that the fund operates within the regulatory framework. The trustees
appoint bankers, custodians and depositories, transfer agents and lastly, and
most importantly, the AMC (if authorized by the Trust Deed) that plays a very
critical role when it comes to achieving the objectives of the mutual fund. The
trustees are responsible for ensuirng that the AMC has proper systems and
procedures in place and has appointed key personnel including Fund Managers and
Compliance Officer.
The AMC
Under the broad supervision and direction of the trustees the Asset Management
Company (AMC) acts as the investment manager of the trust. The AMC charges a
fee for the services that it renders. The trustees delegate the task of
floating schemes and managing corpuses to AMCs, who are investment experts.
Other Supporting Entities
Custodians and Depositories
The custodian is an independent entity which is entrusted with the physical
possession of all securities purchased by the mutual fund. This entity
undertakes the responsibility for handling and safekeeping of the securities,
collection of benefits, etc. Bankers
The bankers play a crucial role with respect to the financial dealings of a
mutual fund by holding its bank accounts and providing it with remittance
services.
Transfer Agents
Transfer Agents are responsible for issuing and redeeming units of the mutual
fund and provide other related services, such as preparation of transfer
documents and updating investors’ records.
Mutual Fund Distributors
The distributors sell mutual funds to investors. They leverage their well
spread out network to market and sell schemes and charge commissions for their
services. They also facilitate redemptions, solve investor grievances, advise
clients on asset allocation, etc. The distributors are paid commissions for the
services rendered in facilitating subscriptions by the fund houses. The
commission paid is upfront and can also be on a trailing basis.
Top
PROS
OF MUTUAL FUND INVESTING
1) Professional Management and Informed
Decision Making
The biggest advantage that mutual funds offer is greater expertise on the
markets, be it the stock market or debt market. The AMC, with its well
organized and structured pool of talent, tracks the economy, companies and
stock market happenings on a day-to-day basis, and investment decisions are
made on the basis of this research. It would be far more difficult for a retail
investor to undertake research of the same magnitude. They have better access
to information than individual investors.
2) Investment Flexibility
Mutual fund houses offer various categories of schemes (equity, debt, hybrid
etc) with a good number of options such as growth, regular income and so on.
You can pick and choose as per your risk appetite, return expectations and
overall investment objective.
3) Portfolio diversity
With a comparatively small capital investment in a mutual fund scheme, you can
gain exposure to a large variety of instruments. In fact, some instruments
which form part of a mutual fund’s portfolio, especially in the debt segment,
are totally out of the reach of a retail investor due to the high threshold
investment limits.
4) Transparency and Safety
No mutual fund guarantees returns but they are transparent in their operations,
since they are subject to stringent disclosure norms. SEBI regulates all mutual
funds operating in India, setting uniform standards for all funds. In addition,
thanks to its three tier structure – clear cut demarcation between sponsors,
trustees and AMCs, conflict of interests can be promptly checked. Lastly, the
Association of Mutual Funds in India works towards promoting the interests of
mutual funds and unit holders. It also launches Investor Awareness Programs
aimed at educating investors about investing in mutual funds.
5) Tax Benefits
Generally, income earned by any mutual fund registered with SEBI is exempt from
tax. However, income distributed to unit holders by a closed end or debt fund
is liable to a dividend distribution tax. Capital gains tax is also applicable
in the hands of the investor, depending on the type of scheme and the period of
holding (See section Tax Benefits and implications of investing in mutual
funds).
Top
CONS OF MUTUAL FUND INVESTING
Impact Cost
Operationally, mutual funds buy and sell in large volumes and voluminous buying
or selling of shares often results in adverse price movements. Funds which buy
in large volumes end up inflating the prices and when funds sell in large
quantities, they tend to depress prices. This could result in high prices while
buying and low prices while selling is called ‘impact cost’
Lead Time
The mutual funds cannot remain fully invested all times due to various reasons.
Firstly, they must maintain some part of their corpus in cash, in order to meet
redemption pressures. Then there could be a time lag between identification of
investment opportunities and actual investment. And finally, it is not possible
for a fund house to deploy money in the market immediately after receiving it
from investors. This lead time when cash is lying idle with mutual funds
results in lower overall returns on the corpus.
Marketing and Fund management costs
In the case of most mutual funds, there is an entry and/or exit load (fee)
applicable while buying and/or selling mutual fund units, respectively. These
loads, which are a certain percentage of the value of units held, are applied
to cover marketing and other costs. In addition to this, the AMC charges annual
asset management fees and expenses, which are captured in the expense ratio.
Cost of churn
Some schemes tend to churn their portfolio very often, in keeping with the
investment philosophy of the fund manager, i.e., whether he/she believes in
long term or short term returns. This means higher transaction costs
(brokerage, custody fees etc) and consequently, lower returns.
TAX
BENEFITS AND IMPLICATIONS OF INVESTING IN MUTUAL FUNDS
The dividend distributed by both debt funds and equity funds is tax-free in
your hands. In case of equity funds, no dividend distribution tax is payable by
the mutual fund. However, in the case of debt funds, the mutual fund has to pay
a Dividend Distribution Tax (DDT) of 14.025 per cent (12.5 per cent tax + 2 per
cent education cess + 10 per cent surcharge) on the amount of dividend
distributed to individuals.
In the case of short term capital gains (profits that accrue from the sale of
units within one year from the date of purchase) earned on the sale of equity
mutual funds, tax is applicable at the rate of 11.22 per cent, if your net
taxable income is above 10 lakh per annum or 10.2 per cent if your net taxable
income is below Rs 10 lakh per annum. Short term capital gains on debt mutual
funds attract tax at the personal income tax rate applicable to you.
Long term capital gains (profits that accrue from the sale of units after one
year from the date of purchase) earned on the sale of equity mutual funds are
tax free in your hands. In case of debt funds, long term capital gains computed
without indexation (indexation involves increasing the cost of your investment
to account for inflation based on the cost inflation index table published by
the government), the tax payable on long term capital gains from debt funds is
22.44 per cent if your income is above Rs 10 lakh per annum or 20.4 per cent if
your income is below Rs 10 lakh per annum. You can choose to calculate your
long term capital gains with or without indexation, depending on which one
results in lower tax payable.
EXPENSES
The Asset Management Company charges an annual fee, or expense ratio that
covers administrative expenses, advertising expenses, custodian fees, etc. An
expense ratio of 1.80 per cent means the AMC has charged Rs 1.80 for every Rs.
100 in assets under management.
A fund's expense ratio is typically linked to the size of the funds under
management and not to the returns earned. Normally, the costs of running a fund
increase at a slower rate than the growth in the fund size - so, the more
assets in the fund, the lower should be its expense ratio. SEBI has prescribed
limits for the maximum expense that can be charged to the scheme.
Top
TYPES
OF MUTUAL FUNDS
1) Mutual funds based on structure
A. Open ended and close-ended schemes
Based on maturity there are two types of mutual fund schemes - open-ended and
close-ended schemes.
Open-ended schemes
These schemes do not have a defined or fixed maturity period. The investors can
buy or sell units on any business day at NAV based prices from the fund house.
Due to this flexibility offered to unit holders, the overall capital of
open-ended schemes can fluctuate on a daily basis.
Close-ended schemes
These schemes have a stipulated maturity period and the fund remains open for
subscription only during a specified period, at the time of launch of the
scheme. Investors can invest in the scheme at the time of the initial public
issue and thereafter, they can buy or sell the units of the scheme on the stock
exchanges where the units are listed.
To provide an exit route to the investors, a few close-ended funds give an
option of selling back the units to the fund house through periodic (usually
monthly or quarterly) repurchase at NAV related prices. SEBI regulations
stipulate that at least one of the two exit routes is provided to the investor
i.e., either repurchase facility or through listing on stock exchanges.
B. Load and No Load Funds
Some mutual funds charge entry or exit loads (fees) when an investor buys or
sells units. These are called “Load funds”. The load is based on the NAV and is
calculated as a certain percentage of the NAV. The load is applied to cover
expenses incurred on the scheme’s marketing, distribution, advertisements, etc.
Because of these charges, your purchase price is higher and your sale price is
lower than the prevailing NAV of the scheme. For instance, if the NAV of a
scheme is Rs 15, and the scheme levies an entry load of 2 per cent, then your
purchase price is 15.30 (NAV + (entry load * NAV)). The number of units that
you would hold is a function of your purchase price and not the NAV. Similarly,
if the NAV of a scheme is Rs 15, and the scheme levies an exit load of 2 per
cent, then your sale price is 14.70 (NAV - (exit load * NAV)). The sum of money
that you receive on redemption is a function of your sale price and not the
NAV. You should consider loads applicable to schemes while investing your money
as it directly impacts your actual returns from the investment.
A ‘no load’ fund does not charge any entry or exit fees.
C. Cumulative or growth schemes, dividend reinvestment
schemes and dividend payout schemes
Mutual funds usually give investors a choice of three ways in which they can
receive their profits from a scheme. These are called the dividend payout
option, the growth option and the dividend reinvestment option.
Dividend payout option - In the dividend payout
option, the profits of the scheme are distributed to the investors in
proportion to the number of units that they hold. This option is suitable for
investors who would like to receive a regular income and for those who would
like to use their profits elsewhere.
Growth option - In the growth option, the profits
are not distributed and accordingly, the value of each unit keeps appreciating
as the profits increase. This option is suitable for investors who do not have
any immediate need for cash and would prefer to reap better wealth in the long
run.
Dividend reinvestment option - Lastly, the dividend
reinvestment option is similar to the growth option, in that the profits are
not distributed. However, here the value of the units is not left to simply
appreciate. Instead, each investor’s profits are converted into more units of
the same scheme at the NAV of the scheme as on the day of conversion. This
option is for those investors who have a medium risk profile and would prefer
to see their capital base grow rather than allow their appreciation to be
eroded by any fall in the value of the scheme’s portfolio.
Top
Mutual funds based on the Portfolio
Allocation
Based on portfolio allocations, there are three broad categories of funds:
-
Equity Funds
-
Debt Funds
-
Balanced Funds
A. Equity Funds
Equity funds invest largely in the shares of companies which are listed on the
stock exchange. Equity funds are basically high risk, high return schemes.
Dividend and capital appreciation are the major revenue streams for equity
funds. The schemes are suitable for investors who are ready to take on some
amount of risk to receive good returns.
All those risks which are associated with equities are associated with these
funds. The NAV will generally move in tandem with the share prices of the
stocks that make up the fund’s portfolio. If the prices of the stocks in its
portfolio fall, the NAV of the schemes too will register a dip.
There are various types of equity funds, key among them include:
Diversified funds
The objective of diversified equity funds is to provide the investor with
capital appreciation over a medium to long term by investing in stocks from
various sectors and segments of the equity market.
Risk and returns: These funds balance their
portfolios so as to prevent any adverse impact on returns due to a downturn in
one or two sectors. Hence, the returns change more or less in tandem with the
broad movement of the stock market.
Suitability: These funds are ideal for investors
who wish to invest in an instrument that delivers equity market linked returns,
without having to build up a large portfolio and monitor it separately.
Sector funds
Sector funds invest only in companies belonging to specific sector mentioned in
the offer document. Normally, sectors that are in the limelight or are
witnessing robust growth are the ones targeted by the mutual fund industry in
order to launch sector funds. The sectoral equity funds dedicated to industries
like technology, bank, pharmaceuticals, infrastructure, etc are good examples
of such funds.
Risk and return: Investment in these funds come
with a higher risk attached, since the investment is spread only across a
single sector. As a result, any adverse policy or environmental change which
affects this sector could result in a huge loss to investors. At the same time,
the profits could be better than those of a diversified fund if the sector
takes off since a bulk of the funds are invested in a winning sector.
Suitability: This fund is suitable for investors who are convinced about the
future prospects of a particular industry and wish to cash in on it. Such
investor must also have the ability to cope with risk.
Theme based funds
Theme based funds are fairly similar to sector funds. The differentiating
factor is the level of diversification that they offer. Instead of
concentrating on stocks belonging to a single sector/industry, their focus lies
on a specific theme and they invest in companies which conform to that theme.
For instance, some theme based schemes invest in only globally competitive
Indian companies or multinational corporations operating in India, others
invest in only those companies which offer a dividend yield above a certain
pre-determined level, and so on.
Risk and return: If the markets favour the chosen
theme, there is a possibility of making very good returns but if they do not,
there are chances of facing losses.
Suitability: These schemes are ideal for investors who also subscribe to the
notion that investing in companies which conform to the selected ‘theme’ will
yield profits.
Index funds
An index funds replicates a selected index, such as the Nifty 50 or the Sensex,
etc., by investing in the same stocks that comprise the index. There are two
types of index funds – Passive Index Funds and Active Index Funds. The former
align their portfolios as accurately as possible to the index and try to hold
index stocks in proportion to the weight-age they enjoy in the index. Active
index funds, on the other hand, aim to give a better return by changing the
weightages of individual stocks and even sectors, as per the fund manager’s
discretion. Such funds may also allocate a certain portion of their portfolio
to non-index stocks.
Risk and return: The performance and returns of
such schemes usually move in sync with that of the index that they try to
replicate. The risk that such funds cGreenArrowy is directly related to the
volatility of the index that they follow.
Suitability: Index funds are recommended for
investors who are satisfied with a return that is approximately equal to that
delivered by the index.
Exchange Traded Funds
Exchange Traded Funds (ETFs) are similar to index funds, in that they too
invest in stocks comprising a particular stock index like the NSE Nifty or the
BSE Sensex. The crucial difference is that an ETF is listed and traded on a
stock exchange while an index fund is bought and sold by the fund and its
distributors.
Risk and return: Like index funds, these funds
follow a passive investment strategy and their risk-return profile is similar
too.
Suitability: There is very little difference
between these funds and index funds structurally, except for the fact that
entry and exit in the case of ETF will attract brokerage while buying and
selling index funds could attract entry and/or exit loads. Investors who wish
to regularly enter and exit index funds may prefer ETFs if they work out more
cost effective.
Top
Equity Linked Savings Schemes
The Equity Linked Savings Schemes are popularly known as ELSS. ELSS is a
variant of diversified equity funds, however, these schemes come along with
income tax benefits. Investment in ELSS is eligible for a tax deduction under
section 80 (C) of the Income Tax Act. However the income tax deduction comes
with a lock-in-period of 3 years. ELSS are governed by ELSS 2005 guidelines of
Central Board for Direct Taxes, Ministry of Finance, Govt of India apart from
the usual SEBI (Mutual Funds) Regulations, 1996.
Risk and return: Such schemes cGreenArrowy the same
risk as equity diversified schemes. Yet they could deliver better returns since
the lock in period gives the scheme’s fund manager the freedom to invest
without fear of redemption pressures.
Suitability: These schemes are suitable for
investors who are looking for a tax break from their mutual fund investment and
can safely lock away their funds for a period of three years.
Mid-cap, Large-cap, Small-cap, Multi-cap Funds
Based on their market capitalisation, companies that are traded on the bourses
can be classified as large caps, mid caps or small caps. Market capitalisation
(also known as market cap) is equal to the total number of equity shares issued
by a company multiplied by the company’s current market price.
Market cap based equity funds invest in stocks that belong to either only one
or two or all three of the stated segments. In other words, at the time of
stock selection, the company's market capitalisation is the basic criteria for
selection.
Risk and return: Each market cap segment has a
different risk-return profile. Investing in small and mid cap stocks could
deliver phenomenal returns if the fund manager’s investment strategy pays off
or they could lose tremendous value. Large caps on the other hand invest in
stocks which are established and unlikely to suddenly lose value. However,
having reached growth plateaus, such stocks are also unlikely to display
spectacular take offs in price. Multi-cap funds, which invest in large cap, mid
cap and small cap stocks, have a profile that is similar to vanilla diversified
equity funds.
Suitability: The level of risk that you are willing
to accept and the returns that you expect will be the criteria for determining
which category of funds you choose to invest in.
Dividend Yield Funds
Dividend yield mutual funds invest in share of companies which have a high
dividend yield ratio. The dividend yield ratio is calculated as the dividend
paid divided by the current market price of the share and represented as a
percentage.
Risk and return: Generally, high dividend yield
stocks have a low beta value relative to benchmark (say the Sensex) and hence
are stable. Besides, dividend yield stocks offer reasonably good returns over
the medium to long term. However, the universe of high dividend yield stocks is
limited.
Suitability: Such schemes are suitable for those
who can invest their capital for a fairly long period of time.
Contra Funds
Contra funds are equity diversified schemes which follow a ‘value investing’
strategy. The fund manager of such schemes looks for stocks of companies which
are fundamentally sound but their values are currently not recognised and
invests before this value is acknowledged by the market.
Risk and return: This strategy could result in
significant capital appreciation if the fund manager’s investment call proves
correct. However, if the fund management team goes wrong in stock selection,
you might not only face a loss but capital erosion too.
Suitability: If you are ready to take on a fair
amount of risk and are not necessarily keen on investing in stocks that are
popular at present, you could consider such schemes.
Top
B. Debt Funds
Debt oriented schemes cater to more conservative investors as they invest all
or a significant portion of their corpus in various debt instruments, such as
company bonds and debentures, treasury bills, government securities, etc. The
income of such funds comes from the interest that the debt instruments held in
the portfolio deliver. In the case of debt instruments that are traded, income
could be accrued in the form of capital appreciation on traded debt paper.
Interest rate movements are the biggest risk factor for debt funds. This is
because the prices of debt instruments and therefore their value share an
inverse relationship with interest rates. The longer the duration of the paper
held by the fund, the higher this risk. Other risk factor is the intrinsic risk
attached to the paper held in the portfolio; for instance government bonds are
risk free but corporate bonds have some risk attached.
There are various types of debt funds, key among them include:
Short term debt funds -
Cash funds, liquid funds and money market funds can be classified as short-term
funds as their portfolios contain instruments that have a maturity of up to one
year such as treasury bills, certificates of deposit, commercial paper, reverse
repo, etc.. The main objective of these funds is to offer investors a liquid
investment avenue that also offers scope for good returns, unlike a bank fixed
deposit which offers low fixed returns.
Risk and returns: The returns from these funds are
not subject to any great risk as the instruments in the corpus can be held to
maturity, unless there are better prospects.
Suitability: These schemes are designed to provide
easy liquidity, preservation of capital and moderate income. Accordingly, they
are ideal for corporates and individual investors who want to park their
surplus funds in a safe but lucrative investment for short periods or until a
more favourable investment alternative emerges.
Medium term debt funds -
Income funds fall into the category of medium term debt funds. These funds have
a time frame of 1-3 years. Income funds have the liberty to invest in longer
maturity instruments, like commercial papers, treasury bills, repos, medium
term bonds, debentures and government securities. These funds also have some of
their corpus invested in short term avenues like the money market and treasury
bills. In addition, if an income fund spots good opportunities in the long-term
maturity segment, it may even invest a small proportion of its funds in fixed
income instruments that have a maturity period of well over 5 years, which
usually offer better returns.
Risk and return: Since redemption pressures on such
funds are less than those on cash/liquid funds, the fund managers can plan
their investment strategies better. However, while income funds offer scope for
better returns, they come tied with greater risks. A rise in interest rates
could impact income funds more severely than it affects shorter-term funds.
Suitability: Investors with short to medium term
horizons who are comfortable with low to medium risk could choose to invest in
income funds.
Long term debt funds - Bond
funds and balanced funds have an investment horizon of three to five years and
therefore fall into the category of long term debt funds. These funds invest in
long term debt instruments which typically offer the highest returns since the
durations are long and there is a direct relationship between the duration of a
bond and its returns.
Risk and returns: Although these funds could offer
greater returns than any other debt fund on the maturity spectrum, they are
open to both credit risks (the risk that the market value of the bond will fall
below the price at which it was purchased, which in turn will cause the NAV of
such funds to fall) and interest rate risks (if interest rates rise, the prices
of bonds fall, as these two factors are inversely related).
Suitability: These funds are suitable for people
who wish to allocate some part of their assets to a variety of long term debt
but may not have enough capital to get such an exposure without the help of a
mutual fund.
Pension schemes – are also
allowed the same tax break that is applicable to ELSS, i.e., an investor can
claim a deduction from taxable income for payments made to specified pension
plans, up to a limit of Rs 1 lakh under Section 80C of the Income Tax Act.
These funds aim to build up a corpus for investors that can be converted into
an annuity on retirement. This annuity will ensure that the investor receives a
regular stream of income post retirement.
Risk and return: These schemes invest most of their
funds in conservative instruments since capital preservation is their prime
objective. Accordingly, the risk exposure of such funds is minimal.
Suitability: Such schemes are ideal for individuals
who are currently in a high tax bracket due to the magnitude of their current
income but expect to witness a drastic fall in income post retirement. Such
individuals can avail of the dual benefit of a tax break at present along with
the comfort that they are saving for their post-retirement years.
Floating Rate Funds –
Some debt instruments are characterised by a floating rate of interest. This
means that the return on such instruments is derived from a particular market
determined interest rate that changes periodically. Debt funds that invest all
or a substantial part of their corpus in such funds are called floating rate
funds. Since the interest rates of the securities held in the portfolios
change, the return on floating rate funds also changes accordingly. Floating
rate funds offer investors the opportunity to receive market related returns.
Risk and return: When interest rates move upwards,
the return of these funds improves but at times when rates are falling,
investors could receive lower returns.
Suitability: Investors who believe that interest
rates will head upwards in the future could go in for floating rate funds.
Gilt Funds The Gilt Funds
invest most of their corpus in sovereign securities, i.e. central and state
government securities. Such schemes can further be further categorized into
short term and long term gilt funds depending on the types of instruments that
they invest in.
Risk and return: Although these funds are almost
risk free, they are subject to interest rate volatility. Whenever the interest
rates are showing a declining trend, they will fetch higher returns due to
appreciation in value of the Gilt portfolio. But in case of an increasing trend
in interest rates, Gilt funds can give low or negative returns.
Suitability: These funds are suitable for those who
wish to play on the interest rate risk.
Top
The Fixed mMaturity Plans (FMPs) are close-ended income schemes with a fixed
maturity. This fixed period of time could range from fifteen days to as long as
two years or more. Moreover similar to an income scheme, FMPs invest in fixed
income instruments like bonds, government securities, money market instruments
and so on.
Risk and return: The returns on such schemes are
fairly predictable since the scheme invests in instruments whose maturity date
coincides with the duration of the plan and the fund manager does not change
the composition of the portfolio unless there is a better opportunity
available.
Suitability: These schemes are somewhat comparable
to fixed deposits and are ideal for investors who are looking for a fixed
return but other benefits of a mutual fund scheme.
C. Balanced Funds / Schemes
The Balanced Schemes invest in equities as well debt instruments. The key
objective here is to blend advantages of equity and debt mutual funds – steady
returns with moderate capital appreciation. Accordingly, the risk and return
profile is somewhere between debt and equity funds.
Monthly Income Plans (MIPs)
The Monthly Income Plans (MIPs) are basically debt schemes that invest small
portion of the portfolio (about10-25% in equities) to boost the scheme’s
returns. There is, however, no assured return in such schemes, unlike the Post
Office Monthly Income Scheme or a Company Deposit.
Risk and return: These funds could offer slightly
better returns than pure long-term debt schemes at marginally higher risk.
Suitability: MIP schemes are ideal for investors
who require a regular income and have a limited appetite for equity investment
risk
Dynamic Asset Allocation Funds
Dynamic asset allocation funds have the flexibility to invest partly/wholly in
equity and/or debt, in line with the limits/parameters that are pre-determined
by the fund house. The main objective of these schemes is to take advantage of
the equity market by entering at lower levels, cashing out at high levels, then
investing the funds in debt/money market instruments and later re-entering
equities when the markets undergo a correction.
Risk and return: Such schemes focus on preservation
of capital but in case the fund management team gets their market timing wrong,
it could lead to erosion of capital. The returns generated by dynamic funds can
be lower than those of diversified equity funds. This is because they may
follow a defensive investment strategy, wherein safety of capital is given
preference over earning higher returns.
Suitability: Since dynamic asset allocation funds regularly reallocate their
portfolio based on market conditions in order to prevent capital erosion, they
are suitable for investors who would like an exposure to equity markets along
with capital stability.
Top
Other Types of Funds
Fund of Funds
The Funds of Funds invest in other mutual funds. The significant benefit of
this scheme is diversification, not only across investments, but also across
Fund Managers.
Evaluation and Monitoring of a Mutual Fund
Scheme
Global funds Invest in the International equity markets. These types of funds
allow the investors to diversify their portfolio across countries thus reducing
country-specific risk.
Arbitrage funds
An Arbitrage Opportunities Fund, is an open-ended equity scheme that aims to
provide capital appreciation and regular income to unit holders by identifying
profitable arbitrage opportunities between the spot and derivative market
segments as also through investment of surplus cash in debt and money market
instruments.
Hedge Funds
A Hedge Funds deploys highly speculative trading strategies in order to protect
its portfolio and gain from short term speculation in the market. These funds
invest in all kinds of instruments including derivatives and their main
objective is to cash in on the arbitrage opportunities using advanced
investment strategies.
Gold Exchange Traded Funds (GETFs)
GETFs are like other Exchange Traded Funds, i.e., units of these funds can be
bought and sold on the exchange on which they are listed in the same manner as
units of equity ETFs. The difference is that the underlying investments in this
case are in gold and gold related instruments. .
Realty Funds
This concept is new to the Indian markets and has recently been approved by
SEBI. These funds can invest in real estate properties and instruments related
to real estate. The core attraction of this product is that even individuals
with relatively small investment amounts have access to real estate investment,
which has been the privilege of big investors over the years.
EVALUATION
AND MONITORING OF A MUTUAL FUND SCHEME
Before you evaluate mutual funds on the basis of a comparison between schemes,
you must keep in mind that there are numerous types of mutual fund schemes in
the market. Besides, there are different ways in which the returns can be
disbursed to unit holders, such as regular dividend payouts, dividend
reinvestment and so on. So, you must be careful that you are not comparing
apples with oranges. Further, if you are trying to measure the performance of a
scheme in comparison to a benchmark, you must ensure that the benchmark is in
fact representative of the index or it could give you an inaccurate picture of
your fund’s performance.
Net Asset Value (NAV) – A basic tool
The first and the most important measure used for evaluating the performance of
a mutual fund scheme is its NAV. The NAV of a mutual fund scheme, which is
determined by dividing the net assets of the scheme by the number of
outstanding units as on particular date, fluctuates up or down depending on the
market value of its investments. The NAVs of open ended schemes are published
on a daily basis in newspapers and available on the web sites of mutual fund
houses. You can also check NAVs on the web site of the Association of Mutual
Funds in India (AMFI)
www.amfiindia.com.
More detailed information about schemes is also available in the form of
half-yearly results published by mutual funds. These results include the fund’s
returns or yields over a period of time, i.e. the last six months, 1 year, 3
years, 5 years and since inception of schemes as well. The results also provide
additional information such as annual expenses as percentage to total assets.
It is mandatory for the mutual funds to dispatch annual reports or abridged
annual reports to unit holders every year.
While the NAV is a primary parameter which helps to evaluate the performance of
the scheme in question, it is not possible to draw any meaningful insights from
merely being aware of the NAV itself. Instead, comparing the NAV of a scheme to
its past levels or checking its performance vis-à-vis the performance of a
benchmark will give you a better picture of the performance of the scheme. Here
are some simple techniques which will help you to gauge the performance of your
scheme using the NAV.
Top
I) Quantitative measures using the NAV
on a stand alone basis
Appreciation/Depreciation of the NAV
The annualized appreciation of a scheme’s NAV, in percentage terms, over the
period for which the performance is to be evaluated gives you a quick measure
of how much your investment has grown (or shrunk).
Illustration of Appreciation / Depreciation in the NAV
You bought units of ABC mutual fund on |
1 January 2005 |
Your purchase price per unit was |
Rs 14.00 |
You want to evaluate the performance of your investment on |
1 June 2006 |
The NAV of each unit of this was on 1 June 2006 was |
Rs 21.00 |
Appreciation in the NAV (NAV on 1 June 2006 minus your
purchase price on 1 January 2005) |
Rs 7.00 (Rs 21.00 minus Rs 14.00) |
Number of days you have stayed invested in the scheme (Number
of days from 1 January 2005 to 1 June 2006) |
517 days |
Percentage appreciation in investment (Appreciation in
NAV/Purchase price x 100) |
50% (Rs 7.00 / Rs 14.00 x 100) |
Annualized percentage appreciation in NAV (Percentage
appreciation in NAV x 365/Number of days you have stayed invested in the
scheme) |
35.30% (50% x 365/517) |
Drawback: Although this NAV-related performance
evaluation is easily understood and universally applicable and accepted, it has
the pitfall of not taking into consideration the dividends declared and paid
out by the mutual fund leading to a technical drop in the NAV. A simple NAV
comparison is suitable if the investor has selected the growth option, under
which no dividends are declared.
Total Return Method
In case you have opted for a dividend payout, you should use the Total Return
Method of evaluating your mutual fund’s performance.
Top
Illustration of Total Return Method
You bought units of ABC mutual fund on |
1 January 2005 |
Your purchase price per unit was |
Rs 14.00 |
Number of units you purchased |
1,000 units |
Total cost of your investment (number of units purchased x
cost per unit) |
Rs 14,000 (1,000 units x Rs.14 per unit) |
On 30 September 2005, the mutual fund declared a dividend of
10% giving you dividends to the tune of |
Rs 1,000 (1,000 units x Rs.10 (Face value) x 10%) |
You want to evaluate the performance of your investment as on |
31 December 2005 |
The NAV of each unit of this was on 31 December 2005 was |
Rs 21.00 |
Appreciation in the NAV (NAV on 31 December 2005 minus your
purchase price on 1 January 2005) |
Rs 7.00 (Rs.21.00 minus Rs 14.00) |
Capital appreciation value is |
Rs 7,000 (1,000 units x Rs7 per unit) |
Total appreciation to your credit (capital appreciation in NAV
+ dividends received) |
Rs 8,000 (Rs 7,000 + Rs 1,000) |
Percentage appreciation (Total appreciation to your credit /
Total cost x 100) |
57.14% |
Since the investment is held for one year, no need
to annualize the return. |
Return with Dividend Reinvestment Option
If you have opted for the dividend reinvestment plan you will get additional
units to the extent of the dividend declared. Reinvestment of the dividend
takes place at the NAV prevailing at the time of dividend declaration. This
will change the cost of your investment. The returns, in this case, have to
take into account both these aspects.
Illustration of Return with Dividend Reinvestment Option
You bought units of ABC mutual fund on |
1 January 2005 |
Your purchase price per unit was |
Rs 14.00 |
Number of units you purchased |
1,000 units |
Total cost of your investment (number of units purchased x
cost per unit) |
Rs 14,000 (1,000 units x Rs.14 per unit) |
On 30 September 2005, the mutual fund declared a dividend of
10% giving you dividends to the tune of |
Rs 1,000 (1,000 units x Rs.10 (Face value) x 10%) |
You have chosen to have this dividend reinvested back into the
scheme at the prevailing NAV of Rs.16.00 (i.e. NAV on 30 September 2005. You
receive additional units (Dividend due / NAV on 30 September 2005) |
62.5 units (Rs 1,000 / Rs 16.00) |
You want to evaluate the performance of your investment on |
31 December 2005 |
The NAV of each unit of this was on 31 December 2005 was |
Rs 21.00 |
Appreciation in the NAV of original units (NAV on 31 December
2005 minus your purchase price on 1 January 2005) |
Rs 7.00 (Rs.21.00 minus Rs.14.00) |
Total appreciation value of original units is |
Rs 7,000 (1,000 units x Rs 7 per unit) |
Appreciation in NAV of new units i.e. units received on
reinvesting dividend) is (NAV on 31 December 2005 minus dividend reinvestment
NAV) |
Rs 5 (Rs.21.00 – Rs 16.00) |
Total value of new units is |
Rs 1312.50 (Rs 21 x 62.5 units) |
Total appreciation (Original units + new units) |
Rs 8,312.50 (Rs 7,000 + Rs.1312.5) |
Total cost of investment |
Rs 14,000 |
Return on investment (Total appreciation / Total cost x 100) |
59.38% (Rs 78,312.50 / Rs 14,000 x 100) |
Since the investment is held for one year, no need
to annualize the return. |
Top
Other measures:
Other measures like Standard Deviation and Sharpe Ratio (not required to be
declared statutorily) can reveal a lot about the fund. Standard Deviation
measures the degree of volatility a fund exposes its investors to, while the
Sharpe Ratio measures returns delivered per unit of risk borne.
II) Measuring Performance vis-à-vis
Benchmark
The method of evaluating performance of mutual funds on standalone basis as
discussed above gives only a partial picture. To make the exercise meaningful,
there has to be a benchmark against which the performance is measured. The
stock indices are good benchmarks for relative comparisons. For instance, if
you want to know whether the performance of any diversified equity mutual fund
has been good or bad, what you can do is simply compare the returns from such
funds with that of the BSE Sensex or the NSE Nifty. You also have broader
indices such as the BSE 100 that would also help you to analyze the performance
of diversified mutual funds.
In market terminology, if the returns generated by a diversified mutual fund
are higher than the Sensex or the Nifty, you could say that the fund has
‘outperformed the market’. And, if the Sensex or the Nifty has reported higher
gains than the fund, the fund has ‘under performed the market’.
However, this comparison applies to diversified mutual funds. If you have
invested in sector funds, these must be compared with the sectoral indices.
Comparing a Pharma fund with a BSE Healthcare index would be more appropriate
than comparing it with the BSE 30 Sensex. The National Stock Exchange and the
Bombay Stock Exchange haves developed various sectoral indices based on sectors
such as banking, pharmaceuticals & healthcare, information technology and
so on.
There are other indices, such as the BSE Mid Cap and the BSE Small Cap, which
can be used as benchmarks to evaluate the performance of mid and small cap
mutual funds.
AMFI Indices
CRISIL, the country’s leading credit rating agency, has developed various
indices in consultation with AMFI (Association of Mutual Funds in India) for
benchmarking the performance of mutual funds with higher component of debt.
These indices act as a representative for a particular group or universe of
schemes. These indices includes
-
CRISIL Composite Bond Fund Index
-
CRISIL MIP Blended Index
-
CRISIL Balanced Fund Index
-
CRISIL Liquid Fund Index
-
CRISIL Short-Term Bond Fund Index
Further, ICICI Securities and Finance Company Ltd (ICICI Securities) in
consultation with AMFI has launched a series of indices for benchmarking the
performance of individual funds against an index that is representative of the
universe of that fund. These indices includes
-
I-Sec Si-BEX
-
I-Sec Mi-BEX
-
I-Sec Li- BEX
-
I-Sec Composite Index
Top
MUTUAL
FUND INVESTING STRATEGIES
In order to help you to simplify the decision of when to invest and disinvest
and make it as beneficial as possible, mutual funds now offer Systematic
Investment Plan (SIP), Systematic Withdrawal Plan (SWP) and Systematic Transfer
Plans (STP).
Systematic Investment Plans
SIPs involve making investments of fixed sums of money in a particular scheme
at predetermined periodical intervals of time (monthly, quarterly or annually).
As this technique results in buying more units when the price is low and less
units when the price is high, it has been found to lower the average cost per
unit purchased, irrespective of whether the market is climbing, falling or
generally volatile. Further, in addition to sparing you from the need to time
the market, it makes investing relatively simple as fund houses allow you to
invest using post dated cheques, ECS transfers, etc.
Systematic Withdrawal Plans
SWPs can be used to regularly disinvest either fixed amounts or some or all of
the appreciation that is generated from your investment in the scheme. This
allows you to receive a regular income from your investment in a scheme or
simply invest the gains from the scheme elsewhere. All you have to do to
utilize this facility is fill in a form that is available with the fund house,
intimating them about your preferences (fixed or appreciation withdrawal).
Systematic Transfer Plans
Through STPs you can transfer fixed amounts of money at regular intervals
(monthly or quarterly) from one scheme to another. You can activate this
facility by giving your fund house one-time standing instructions to execute
such transfers. These plans effectively automate both the processes of
investing and disinvesting.
MUTUAL
FUNDS V/S PORTFOLIO MANAGEMENT SERVICES (PMS)
In portfolio management services, the portfolio manager advises or directs the
client on how he should invest his portfolio of securities or funds. The
services could be discretionary or non-discretionary. In case of discretionary
services, the approval of the client is required before investments are made
whereas in case of non discretionary services, the portfolio manager makes
investment decision on the basis of parameters that have been agreed upon
between the client and the portfolio manager.
Comparison between mutual funds and PMS
-
The cost of investing is higher in the case of portfolio management services as
compared to mutual funds.
-
The minimum investment in portfolio management is very high as compared to
mutual funds.
-
Mutual funds offer hassle free investing as the investor need not continuously
track individual stocks, which may be required in case of portfolio management.
CHECKLIST
FOR MUTUAL FUND INVESTING
-
Draw up your asset allocation.
-
Identify funds that fall into your buy list.
-
Obtain and read the offer documents. You could do this online on
IDBIpaisabuilder.in or by either asking your broker or the asset management
companies.
-
Match your objectives with that of the fund. Read through the offer documents
and check to see whether the mutual funds identified meet your investment needs
in terms of equity share and bond weightage, downside risk protection, tax
benefits offered, dividend payout policy, sector focus etc.
-
Check out the fund’s past performance.
-
Look for `load' costs, annual expenses of the fund and sales loads. These can
take away a significant portion of your returns.
-
Look for size and credentials. As far as possible, avoid investing in funds
with an asset base of less than Rs 25 crores.
-
Check out the customer service delivery mechanism of the mutual fund you
choose. Can you get in touch with them easily? How often do they send you
portfolio updates? Do they circulate investor newsletters?
-
Diversify, but not too much. Do not hold just one fund in each asset category.
-
Monitor regularly and review your mutual fund portfolio. Try to review your
mutual fund holdings at least once a quarter. You can do it easily on the
portfolio tracker at IDBIpaisabuilder.in 11. Invest regularly through the SIP
option. It will work in your interest.
Top
MYTH
BUSTERS
Myth 1:
New Fund Offerings (NFOs) offer a better deal than existing
funds It is better to buy units in a new fund offering at Rs 10 than an
existing fund at a higher NAV.
Reality:
The performance of the mutual fund whether existing or new scheme solely
depends on factors like the skills and investment strategies adopted by the
fund managers, quality of the portfolio, exposure to various industries and so
on. In fact, when it comes to investment there is no difference between new
schemes selling at par value or existing schemes selling at higher price. The
return, as a percentage of the capital which you have invested, will determine
which investment was a better choice.
Myth 2:
Shares generate higher returns The stock market is more exciting and direct
investing in shares generates higher returns than mutual funds.
Reality:
The returns the mutual funds generate depend on the type of mutual fund scheme
you select. That goes for shares too; the return you receive could be good or
bad depending on the stock that you choose. For instance, index funds usually
report returns that are in sync with the index which they try to mirror while
pure equity funds can outperform the index by a wide margin.
Myth 3:
Investing in mutual funds is an expensive proposition Mutual funds charge
various expenses such as entry and exit loads, annual asset management fees and
other expenses.
Reality:
Though mutual funds levy various fees they are not an
expensive proposition. When you invest directly too there are certain expenses
that you will have to bear. In fact, the additional charges that you pay
towards fund management, etc., end up benefiting you since it results in
investment decisions which are better researched and more meticulous monitoring
of the performance of your investments on a continuous basis.
Myth 4:
Mutual funds guarantee returns Some mutual funds assure their
investors a certain level of returns.
Reality:
Mutual funds are subject to market risks and do not guarantee
any kind of returns to unit holders. The performance of mutual fund schemes
should be compared with benchmark indices and judged accordingly. It is quite
possible that even the best of fund managers may not be able to deliver
consistent returns over the years.
Myth 5:
Lower NAVs translate into better investment opportunities Mutual funds with
lower NAVs can generate better returns.
Reality:
Low NAVs do not mean a ‘cheap’ investment opportunity. You need to look at the
long term returns generated by the scheme in question. Here, returns mean
capital appreciation and dividend paid, if applicable. The track record of the
fund manager and the composition of the portfolio of the schemes are also
critical factors which you should consider while choosing the right scheme.
Top
JARGON
BUSTER
Account Statement
- A statement issued by the mutual fund house, giving details
of transactions and holdings of an investor. This is normally issued in lieu of
a unit certificate.
Asset Allocation
- When you divide your money among various types of
investments, such as stocks, bonds, and short-term investments (also known as
"instruments"), you are allocating your assets. The way in which your money is
divided is called your asset allocation.
Benchmark
- A parameter against which the performance of a scheme can be compared. For
example, the performance of an equity scheme can be benchmarked against the BSE
Sensex. In this case, the BSE Sensex will be known as the benchmark index.
Beta
- It shows the sensitivity of the fund to movements in the
benchmark. A beta of more than 1 indicates an aggressive fund and the value of
the fund is likely to rise or fall more than the benchmark. A beta of less than
1 implies a defensive fund that will rise or fall less than the benchmark. A
beta of 1 indicates that the fund and the benchmark will react identically.
Cut-off time
- In respect of all mutual funds regulated by SEBI, fresh
subscriptions and redemptions are processed at a particular NAV. Every fund
specifies a cut-off time in respect of fresh subscriptions and redemption of
units. All requests received before the cut-off time are processed at that
day's NAV and thereafter, at the next day's NAV.
Dividend
- When companies pay part of their profits to shareholders,
those profits are called dividends. A mutual fund's dividend is money paid to
shareholders from investment income the fund has earned. The amount of each
share's dividend depends on how well the company has performed.
Growth Fund
- A mutual fund whose primary investment objective is
long-term growth of capital. It invests principally in common stocks with
significant growth potential.
Income Fund
- A mutual fund that primarily seeks current income rather
than growth of capital. It will tend to invest in stocks and bonds that
normally pay high dividends and interest.
Load
- A sales charge or commission charged by certain mutual funds
("load funds") to cover their selling costs.
Portfolio Churning
- Switching investments between different stocks in the
market, with a view to give unit holders a better yield by taking advantage of
market conditions.
Record Date
- The date on which the fund determines who its unitholders
are; "unitholders of record" receive the fund's income dividend and/or net
capital gains distribution.
Top
|